Xing-shan
性善 (xìng shàn)
Mencius’s cardinal thesis: human nature is originally good. Not that man is incapable of evil, but that, left to his first impulse, he tends toward good; evil is not the result of natural endowment but of its abandonment. Goodness, then, is not a program to be imposed from without—it is the native inclination that education preserves or neglect neglects. (*Confucianism* has no proper entry in the nomenclature: the term is classified there as cross-cutting.)
If you let people follow their feelings (original nature), they will be able to do good. This is what is meant by saying that human nature is good.
« If you allow people to follow their feelings (their original nature), they will be able to do good. This is what is meant by saying that human nature is good. »
Xing (性) is nature—what a being is at birth; shan (善), goodness. Against his opponent Gaozi, who holds nature to be indifferent—neither good nor bad, like water that flows wherever it is directed—Mencius argues that, left to itself, it inclines toward good, just as water flows downward.
The proof is not speculative but affective. Compassion, shame, deference, and the sense of right and wrong « are present in all men »: these are the Four Beginnings, the seeds through which goodness manifests from the outset. That man does evil does not disprove this: « it is not the fault of his natural endowment. » Evil arises from loss, from failed cultivation, from the choked seed—never from nature itself.
The stakes are to ground humaneness prior to any conditioning: if love for others is innate, then moral effort does not add to man but restores him. To cultivate the heart-mind is to return to one’s original disposition rather than conform to an external rule; it is to let native sincerity operate rather than manufacture it.
Xing-shan ≠ the siduan it founds: the latter name the four particular seeds, while the former states the general thesis on nature for which these seeds are proof. It ≠ the doctrine of a neutral nature (Gaozi) or an evil one (Xunzi): for Mencius, man is not raw material to be shaped, but a goodness not to be lost.