The Ethics of the Earth: Soil as Subject or Biotic Community?

Two Voices on Our Relationship to the Ground

The Ethics of the Earth: Soil as Subject or Biotic Community?
USDA NRCS South Dakota — 2012 Soil Health Information Day, Mitchell, SD (8267454489). Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

The earth appears differently depending on the gaze that rests upon it. Two fragments—one from the Upanishads, the other from Aldo Leopold—offer distinct glimpses of it. The first evokes a presence, the second a dynamic. Neither proposes a synthesis, but each suggests a way of dwelling in the world.

A Diffuse and Sought-After Presence

The Upanishads name the soil in terms that emphasize its expanse and allure:

Widely scattered, desired everywhere.

Upaniṣad (śruti), Upaniṣad, part I — Chandogya (Khandogya), Kena (Talavakara), Aitareya, Kaushitaki, Isa , book Asvalayana Grvhya-sftras, § I, 13, 7  — ed. after the French translation by F. Max Müller, Sacred Books of the East, vol. I, Oxford, 1879, trans. viasophia

These words do not describe a function or composition, but a dispersion and a longing. The soil is not confined: it spreads. It is not indifferent: it is sought. The phrasing does not specify who desires it, or why, but it presents the soil as a reality that calls for relationship.

A Dynamic Shaped by Consequences

In his Sand County Almanac, Aldo Leopold observes a phenomenon in which the soil becomes the revealer of an imbalance:

Dust Bowl: in the early 1930s, across the southern Midwest, the overexploitation of farmland combined with prolonged drought caused dust storms to strip away the topsoil, triggering an ecological and social catastrophe.

Aldo Leopold, Almanach d un comt des sables  — ed. after the original English edition, *A Sand County Almanac*, trans. viasophia

Here, the soil is not a diffuse presence but an element caught in a chain of causes and effects. Overexploitation and drought alter its structure, and this alteration has repercussions that extend beyond the merely physical. The passage speaks neither of community nor reverence, but of a system in which human actions reshape the conditions of existence.

Two Fragments, Two Perspectives

The Upanishads say nothing of the mechanisms governing the soil, nor of the consequences of its exploitation. They evoke a quality: widely scattered, desired everywhere. This dispersion and longing are not explained, but they suggest a relationship that is not primarily instrumental.

Leopold, for his part, does not speak of desire or metaphysical presence. He describes a process: the earth, subjected to pressures, responds in visible ways. The catastrophe he recounts is not a condemnation but an observation. It shows that the soil is not a mere substrate but an element whose transformations set off cascading effects.

These two fragments do not oppose each other. Nor do they complement one another. They offer two ways of considering the soil: one as a reality that offers itself and draws us in, the other as a system that endures and reacts. Neither prescribes an attitude, but each invites a particular attention.

Sources cited

  • Upaniṣad (śruti), Upaniṣad, part I — Chandogya (Khandogya), Kena (Talavakara), Aitareya, Kaushitaki, Isa, ed. Sacred Books of the East, vol. I, Oxford, 1879, trans. F. Max Müller (1879).
  • Aldo Leopold, Almanach d un comt des sables, ed. .