French · Western philosophy

Plan de consistance

In Deleuze and Guattari, the *plane of consistency* is the plane of immanence where multiplicities compose themselves directly, through relations of speed and slowness, without any form or subject organizing them from above. It stands opposed to the *plane of organization*: the latter is a hidden, transcendent principle, existing in an additional dimension beyond what it orders; the plane of consistency, by contrast, never has one more dimension than what unfolds upon it. It does not preexist the movements that trace it—one does not discover it, one constructs it.

Ce plan, qui ne connaît que les longitudes et les latitudes, les vitesses et les heccéités, nous l’appelons plan de consistance ou de composition (par opposition au plan d’organisation et de développement). C’est nécessairement un plan d’immanence et d’univocité.
Gilles Deleuze & Félix Guattari, Mille Plateaux. Capitalisme et schizophrénie 2, Plateau « 1730 — Devenir-intense, devenir-animal, devenir-imperceptible… ». Éditions de Minuit, coll. « Critique », 1980

Deleuze and Guattari distinguish two ways of conceiving a plane. The plan d’organisation is a hidden principle: it governs the development of forms and the formation of subjects, yet never presents itself directly—it can only be inferred from its effects. A design in the mind of a god, a secret structure, a score placed beside the music: it always occupies an additional dimension beyond what it yields. It is a plane of transcendence.

The plan de consistance proceeds differently. No forms, no subjects—only relations of movement and rest, of speed and slowness between unformed elements; affects, individuations without subject that produce collective assemblages. Consistency does not mean logical coherence: it is the holding-together of heterogeneous elements that compose directly, like a rhizome connects without hierarchizing. The plane of consistency is the body without organs. And it does not preexist the movements of deterritorialization that unfold it, the lines of flight that trace it, the becomings that compose it: it is built, piece by piece, and the two planes never cease working on each other—the one plugs the leaks, the other sends particles streaming beyond strata. Hence the required caution: if destratified too quickly, the plane of consistency turns into a plane of abolition.

Plane of consistency ≠ preestablished harmony or Stoic cosmic order. Those orders are given in advance, guaranteed by a reason that overlooks the world and assigns it its end. The plane of consistency is guaranteed by nothing: without finality, without an overarching dimension, it exists only insofar as it is traced.

← back to the lexicon