Mourning as an Act of Resistance
Grieving what vanishes between illusion and memory
Mourning is not one emotion among others. It carves a furrow where something vaster than sorrow unfolds: a confrontation with what fades away. Two voices, distant in time and space, offer readings that seem to stand in opposition. One urges us to see beyond loss; the other, to make it the foundation of struggle. These perspectives do not cancel each other out. Instead, they sketch the contours of a tension in which mourning becomes both what eludes us and what commits us.
Loss as an Illusion to Dissolve
Shankara proposes a path where mourning dissolves in the light of a higher knowledge. What affects us, what wrings tears from us, is not ultimate reality. The assumptions of those who cling to appearances cannot alter what is.
The presuppositions of the deeply deluded cannot condition reality, just as a great torrent seen in a mirage cannot wet the desert.
The comparison is striking. The torrent glimpsed in the desert is but an image, a projection of the mind. It does not moisten the sand, nor does it quench thirst. Likewise, what seems lost to us—a person, a world, an era—may be nothing more than an appearance, a fleeting form that knowledge allows us to traverse. Here, mourning is not denied. It is put into perspective, placed within a framework where what matters is not what disappears, but what endures beyond forms.
This approach does not erase pain. It shifts its status. Mourning becomes a sign—not of the reality of loss, but of the illusion that binds us to it. It is not an act to be performed, but a stage to be transcended. Resistance, in this view, does not consist in fighting against erasure, but in recognizing that what fades was but a shadow.
Loss as a Call to Protect
Davi Kopenawa offers a radically different reading. Mourning is not an illusion to transcend, but a political act, a way of resisting annihilation. What vanishes is not a passing form, but an entire world, with its living, its dead, its laws.
This is why our deceased shamans are angry and wish to protect us. If our breath of life is cut short, the forest will become empty and silent.
The anger of the ancient shamans is not a metaphor. It is an active force, a reaction to the threat hanging over what has been. Here, mourning is not a stage to be crossed, but a call to action. To grieve what disappears is already to refuse its erasure. It is to keep alive what is fading away.
The empty, silent forest is not an abstract image. It is the concrete consequence of an interruption, of a breath that ceases. Mourning thus becomes an act of memory, but also of struggle. It is not about resignation, but about protecting what remains, ensuring that silence does not settle in.
Two Ways of Inhabiting Erasure
These two voices do not clash head-on. They reveal, rather, two ways of inhabiting erasure, two responses to what departs.
Shankara invites us to see beyond. What disappears is not ultimate reality, but one form among others. In this perspective, mourning is an invitation to recognize that what truly matters cannot be lost. It is not an act, but a dissolution.
Kopenawa, for his part, turns mourning into an act. To grieve what vanishes is already to resist oblivion, to keep alive the memory of what has been. The silent forest is not a fate, but a consequence to be averted. Mourning becomes a force, a means of protecting what remains.
These two approaches do not contradict each other. They complement one another, like two possible answers to the same question: what to do with what fades? One proposes seeing beyond; the other, acting here and now. One relativizes loss; the other makes it the foundation of struggle.
Mourning as an Open Question
Mourning is not a problem to be solved, but a question to be inhabited. There is no single answer, only paths to explore. Shankara and Kopenawa do not offer solutions, but propositions. One invites us to recognize that what affects us may be but an appearance. The other reminds us that what disappears deserves to be mourned, protected, kept alive.
Between these two voices, mourning unfolds as a space of tension. It is neither to be denied nor absolutized. It is what passes through us, what questions us, what commits us. It is not an end, but a beginning—a way of situating ourselves in relation to what is, to what departs, to what remains.
Sources cited
- Shankara, Vivekachudamani, ed. .
- Davi Kopenawa, La Chute du ciel, ed. Plon, coll. Terre humaine, 2010, trans. Bruce Albert (propos yanomami recueillis et traduits).